COUNSELING EDUCATION & SUPERVISION

QUALITATIVE MANUSCRIPT EVALUATION

Manuscript Code Reviewer Code Review Due
Manuscript Title:
Category: [Counselor Prep] [Supervision] [Profess. Devel.] [Current Issues] [Innovative Methods]
   
I. INTRODUCTION TO THE MANUSCRIPT AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
A. Sufficient Rationale for Study & Design AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
B. Research Question Identified AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
II. METHOD SECTION  
A. Participants & Setting (described in detail) AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
B. Data Collection Procedures AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
C. Researcher Bias Addressed AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
D. Data Analysis AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
E. Validation Procedures AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
F. Limitations AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
III. RESULTS/DISCUSSION  
A. Identification of Themes/Patterns AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
IV. MANUSCRIPT COMPONENTS  
A. Pertinent Literature Reviewed AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
B. Literature Reviewed Organized and Focused AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
C. Research Reviewed and Critiqued in Article AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
D. Conclusions Drawn Logically AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
E. Practical Implications AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
F. Directions for Research AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
G. If Innovations and Methods Section Included:  
    1. Sufficient detail provided for substantiation AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
    2. Sufficient detail provided for implementation AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
V. WRITING STYLE, GRAMMAR, APA FORMAT AcceptableUncertainUnacceptable
VI. WRITTEN FEEDBACK TO AUTHORS:
VII. RECOMMENDATION FOR DISPOSAL

Accept as Is

Accept after Modifications

Revision and Review

Rewrite, Resubmit and Review

Reject - Unsound

Reject-Inappropriate for CE&S; the Following Journals Are Suggested: